On the surface, T. Boone Pickens’ energy plan
appears to be a good plan that will go a long ways towards curing
the country of its foreign oil dependency and prevent the massive
amount of money that we are sending out of the country to foreign
oil producing nations each year. It also would appear, on the
surface, that Boone is doing this for the good of the country since
Boone, at 80 years old will most likely not live to see the return
on his investment.
The plan seems fairly uncomplicated. Boone
wants to take the natural gas that’s currently being used to
generate electrical power and transfer its use to the transportation
sector eliminating as much as 20% of our oil usage for vehicles. He
would replace the natural gas being used in the energy sector with
wind farms. This would save us up to $300 billion per year in oil
purchases and keep the money in the country where it could be spent
on the cost of the conversion.
During the process, the domestic wind energy industry would
be stimulated and communities and manufacturers would enjoy
significant economic benefits. This stimulus would also bleed off
into other renewable energy industries. We have already seen this to
be the case with the wind and solar power industries growing at 30%
per year. Small communities with wind farms are experiencing much
needed economic growth and farmers who lease their land to power
companies for wind turbine planting are beginning to buy new farm
equipment with the additional income. This is obviously a good thing
for the country.
Questions arise when you look at the other
things that Boone Pickens is doing and how he is doing them. Boone
has formed Mesa Power and Mesa Water. With Mesa Power he is using
the government power of eminent domain to seize privately owned land
and lay power lines from his wind farm in the Texas panhandle to
Dallas. A drive from Dallas to El Paso takes about 12 hours. A
number of people along this long route are being forced to go along
with the plan whether they like it or not.
People have to have water and will pay whatever
it costs. You can’t just start doing something like riding a bike
instead of using it. With Mesa Water, Boone is using the power of
imminent domain to buy up water rights to the water supply provided
by the Ogallala Aquifer and construct a water pipeline along the
same route from the 68,000 acres he owns in the Texas panhandle to
Dallas. He now owns more water than any other person in the United
States and plans on selling it to Dallas and said, at the age of 78,
that he would invest $1 billion into this project over the next 30
years.
Looking at the his energy plan alone, even
though Boone has vast holdings in natural gas, he is talking about
using the same amount of natural gas, not more, so, there is no
benefit for him personally. He even admits that the use of natural
gas in transportation is temporary and only a bridge to new electric
and hydrogen technology. He has spoken of this on national
television saying that the need for this is much bigger than his
need for personal gains.
Something curiously missing from Pickens' plan
is support for the independently owned power companies who provide
power for most of the rural area that the plan focuses on. These
smaller utility companies are looking at rising fuel and maintenance
costs on aging infrastructures and they are grasping at wind farms
as a solution. There are already wind farm projects in 40 states as
a result of their efforts. Supporting them would be an easy thing to
do through the already existing Rural Utility
Service with more low interest guaranteed loans. They don't want
handouts, they always pay their bills, and they don't need or
want the
regulation
that comes with government money in the form
of a stimulus.
Then you think about what he is doing with Mesa
Water and Mesa Power and you begin to wonder, if at the age of 80,
he isn’t just looking to make the big deal to be remembered for. He has also more than
doubled his political contributions. Then, as you find out more about Boone's investments, you learn
that Nonacy Pelosi has also invested in a Boone Picken's company named CLNE. The
stock gets a hit with each new announcement.
Men worship different gods. There is no doubt
that our Founding Fathers tried their best to
create a great country that would be long lasting for us and
their names are permanently carved in history. On the other hand, John
Rockefeller died knowing that, by making close to the equivalent of
$1 trillion in today’s money by financing both sides of WWI, he was
forever deified among his peers. Wealthy men donate millions to
their favorite universities so that they will be reverently
whispered about in campus hallways.
Which is T. Boone Pickens? Is this good old
country boy out to quench our thirst and reduce our dependency on
foreign oil or is he just trying to make the big deal that will make
his name live forever? Mounting evidence favors the latter. We do
not need a national energy plan that will only serve to empower the
already rich and take the freedom away from our independent
power companies to prosper. We don't need a bubble creating
stimulus
that will
only serve to rob the industry of the capital it needs to expand
and create technology.