I am a former SSGT
with the USAF and my Father served in the Army Air Corp in the
Pacific and receiving 2 Gold Stars and three Purple Hearts. My
family is related to General Patton and 13 members of the
Revolutionary Army. One of our other family members, Mial Scurlock,
died at the Alamo. We have served during every war that the United
State has waged. We are members of the DAR, SAR, and VFW. Our family
heritage is deep in military service.
My son, Christopher
Adam Smith, serving in the family tradition, also entered the Air
Force at a time that he was already able to exceed all of the
physical requirements that he would be faced with while in basic
training. He could already run faster, do more push-ups, and more
set-ups than the Air Force would ask. While in basic, he was asked
to set up a tent and had to pound stakes into very hard ground. The
sledgehammer that he was given to use had a broken handle and he had
to hold the hammer with his hand touching the head. There was no
other hammer available and he had to hit the stake hard to get the
stake to penetrate the hard ground. On one of his strikes, the head
slipped off of the stake and his finger struck the stake’ being
powered by the force from the hammerhead’ breaking it in eight
places. Prior to breaking his finger, he was doing very well in
basic and his Training Instructor liked him. During his time in
basic, even though he was told that his pay had been deposited, he
learned that the Air Force was actually depositing his check into
another Chris Smith’s account after he was notified that his account
had been overdrawn for $10 worth of soft drinks out of machines and
he was charged $300 in overdraft fees.
Chris was sent to a
medical squadron while his hand healed and, despite his injury, he
did well in his limited assignment and was well liked by the people
in charge. He was put in charge of various details and made
responsible for seating 300 people at the dining facility. He was
also asked to escort other patients to the mental facilities when
they became unruly. His finger was not properly repaired and now, as
a result of being forced to use defective tools, he is unable to
close his hand completely and his finger remains deformed. After his
finger healed, he was sent back to finish basic and completed it
with no incidents. His first TI recommended him to his new
TI.
Chris was then sent to
Sheppard Air Force Base to undergo training as an aircraft refueler.
In addition to technical training classes, Sheppard assigns
increasing amounts of liberties to its trainees in phases 1, 2, and
3. Trainees are also required to carry documents called 341s with
them to give to other Air Force personnel who see them violating
rules. The 341s are turned into the squadron by the person writing
the trainee up and every permanent party junior airman and on up can
ask a trainee for a 341. NCOs that the trainees report to then have
the option of converting the 341s in to much more serious Letters of
Reprimand (LORs).
When Chris first
started his training at Sheppard, he initially had some trouble with
the high-paced academic setting, but through his own initiative, he
was able to develop a study routine that eliminated his academic
problems. He was cruising though his last week in his final block,
in Phase 3, had received orders to go to England, had been through
processing, and his belongings had been shipped. He was doing well
in his studies and spent his evenings running, lifting weights, and
playing handball to keep in shape and watching movies and playing
video games in his dorm room. He does not drink or do drugs and has
never stolen anything. His Military Training Leader liked him and
his MSGT had checked him out in the refueling truck and said that he
knew what he was doing. In spite of what had happened, with his pay
and hand, he still liked the Air Force and was looking forward to
his tour of duty in England. Then the following unfortunate series
of events occurred.
He was going over his
class notes while eating at the dining facility and left his
notebook on the chair next to him when he left. The notebook
contained all of his work for his final block 4, which he had
already completed even though he had a week left. He discovered this
when he arrived at his classroom the next morning, Friday the 13th,
and reported it to his Military Training Leader. Chris was given
a LOR when he reported
to his MSGT. He took the initiative to redo all of the work in Block
4 over the next 3 days during his off-duty time.
In the meantime, Chris
had also noticed additional strange activity with his bank account.
$400 had been deducted from his account and his pay was not being
deposited at his new B of A account. He was at payroll trying to get
things squared away and called me on his cell phone to log into his
bank account and collect information. Denver had deposited pay in
his B of A account belonging to a Chris Andrew Smith and had taken
it out about three weeks later, but my son's pay was still being
deposited in his USBank account. Chris was well aware of the rules
concerning using electronic devices while in uniform and was obeying
them, but for some reason did not consider a cell phone an
electronic device. A woman in accounting asked for his 341 and he
was given another LOR.
For his punishment for
the two LORs, he was set back in class two weeks and busted to phase
1 for a week.
Some airmen are given
ropes to wear on their shoulders and given the task of marching
formations to school. While standing at attention in formation the
next morning, airmen around him were talking. The rope in charge
looked over, did not see who was talking, but issued Chris a 341
because he said that his hat was too small. This was the same hat
that he was measured for and issued in basic training. For getting
the 341, Chris was issued another LOR and busted back to phase 1 for
another week when talking to his new MTL, SSGT Smith, and his new
MSGT Taylor. MSGT Taylor told Chris to type up reports on the
rulebook and a response as to why his hat was too small. The rope
that issued the 341 did not make it through rope school and was
relieved of his duty.
The following Friday,
he checked the weekend detail roster after work and his name was not
on it. That evening around 23:30, he was awakened by pounding on his
dorm room door and yelling that the detail roster was being created.
Early Saturday morning, there was again pounding and yelling on his
door saying that he was on detail and that he had better get down
stairs. Chris jumped up and rushed down but was 5 minutes late.
Chris was put in charge of four Airmen and managed to type his
reports for MSGT Taylor during lunchtime on Sunday. Even though the
NCO in charge of the detail gave Chris a Letter of Achievement (LOA)
as a result of his good work on the weekend detail, he was given
another LOR for being late. SSGT Smith and MSGT Taylor then said
that they were going to throw Chris out of the Air Force.
That evening, SSGT
Smith pulled a surprise inspection on Chris's dorm room. Chris was
in his room and with his locker door unlocked and a bag of trash
that he was getting ready to take down to the garbage. SSGT Smith
said that the unlocked locker door was a security violation and
wrote him up for that and the bag of trash. Chris's roommate was not
there but had also left his locker door unopened. SSGT Smith accused
Chris of breaking into it. A short while after SSGT Smith left, two
more NCOs came into Chris's room and searched his locker. There was
no contraband or anything in the locker that was not supposed to be
there.
MSGT Taylor told Chris
that he was going to be sent to another squadron and to pack up his
belongings. Chris was called downstairs at about 22:30 that night
and told to report to Lt. Col. Neil the next day. Lt. Col.
Neil told him that he was going to be processed out of the Air
Force. Chris was supposed to re-enter Block 4 the next day and had
already done all of his work for the entire 2-week class and planned
to do it an additional number of times to make sure that he did
well.
After reporting to Lt.
Col. Neil, Chris developed a severe headache and went to the
hospital for treatment. He had been accidentally tripped by another
airman in basic training while going down some stairs and fallen and
struck his head hard enough to temporarily make him briefly lose
consciousness. He did not report to the hospital at the time because
he thought that, having already been injured due to faulty
equipment, he would get in trouble and he had been dazed
previously from hard hits when he was playing hockey to no ones
great concern. He now has a dent in his skull and had suffered
increasingly painful headaches and felt constant pressure.
Chris thought that if he was going to be thrown out that he should
get his head looked at first. Instead of being processed out, he was
put on medical status in his dorm room and told to report to his NCO
every hour to make sure that he is OK. He was scheduled for various
medical tests.
On 4/27, while leaving
his dorm room to report for his hourly check in, he forgot to sign
out and was given another LOR.
On 4/30, he was told
to pull Road Guard duty in his Physical Training clothes and given
no instruction. While moving a few steps to tell a driver that she
was not going to be able to get out if she parked in a location, he
was moving his hands around as he was explaining. Someone was
watching him and issued him a 341, which was transferred into
another LOR.
On 4/30, a note was
posted on the bulletin board informing Airmen to wear their sleeves
rolled up. Chris did not know if he was supposed to wear them rolled
up in the dining facility so he did not go to eat to avoid more
trouble.
One evening while
talking to him, he seemed very depressed about the situation and as
he hung up I was concerned about the way he said good-bye. I tried
calling him back a few times, but could not reach him. I called the
medical clinic on base and expressed my concern. I was told that a
nurse would call me back shortly. In the meantime I kept trying to
call Chris and finally got a hold of him and he had settled down. No
nurse ever did call me, but I learned later that they had left a
message with Chris’s squadron that I had called saying that Chris
was depressed. The squadron did not pick up the message until the
next day, which might have been too late.
Later the following
week, another Airman flung the door open from the bathroom hitting
Chris’s big toe and apparently breaking it. Chris went to the
medical clinic and was told that his toe was in fact broken and it
was simply bandaged up. Later, when Chris reported to the hospital
off base for a cat scan, a doctor looked at his toe and said it was
simply dislocated and popped it back into place relieving Chris of
the pain that he had been suffering. Chris had played hockey for 10
years, driven forklift at Home Depot for a year handling tons of
construction supplies, and worked on construction sites without
suffering a smashed finger.
During a period of 2-3
weeks while Chris was on medical status, he was assigned to wash
windows everyday and he did this for the entire time without
complaining. He was also told during this time that he was going to
be put back into Block 4 so that he could finish his training and go
on to his permanent assignment. All of Chris’s medical tests came
back negative and he was released to active duty expecting to go
back into training. He was immediately told to report for his
discharge physical because he was going to be discharged. He
reported to his commander on May 5th and was told that he
would be discharged in one week.
A
TSGT in the sqradron and Area Defense Counsel have told Chris
that his mistakes are not the types of things that people are
discharged for. I have found the number
for the Area Defense Counsel for members of the Air Force, who
get into this type of situation, but they refuse to talk to me and
Chris’s morale and attitude have been destroyed and he refuses to
call them again to learn about his rights and make sure that he is
protected. He says that the rules are not being enforced for everyone and that
some people are breaking actual laws for things like underage drinking and being allowed
to stay in. He just wants out of the Air Force now and is
very depressed. This is, no doubt, exactly what SSGT Smith and MSGT
Taylor wanted.
The thing that most likely bothers the people involved in
this is that, while Chris is respectful and makes every attempt to
obey his orders, he will not cower and he
will not be broken. His conversation and answers tend to
be abrupt and truthful. "Yes sir. I made a mistake." "No sir. I did
not do that." These individuals are trying to lead by making the people reporting
to them afraid instead of earning their respect. Chris is not afraid and they know
it.
The Air Force is
obviously in need of some leadership training for its NCOs to
prevent this type of thing from happening in the future and Sheppard
needs to revise its 341 and LOR process to make sure that the
careers of otherwise good soldiers are not destroyed by unqualified
immature incompetents who do not understand the consequences of
their actions.
As you can see, a
number of unfortunate, but harmless events and mistakes snowballed
on Chris at a time when he was doing very well, had performed above
standards, and was on his way to having a successful career in the
Air Force and making a contribution to his country. Without any
prior knowledge of Chris or the skills to do their jobs, these NCOs
allowed their attitudes towards Chris to be affected and they
mounted a campaign to force Chris out of the Air Force. Even Chris's
attitude, which had been unbending, was affected. He says that he
has come fully loaded every single time, ready to do their bidding,
but they don’t respect him. He is not insubordinate. The Air Force
is going to lose a very good soldier and Chris will have his future
severely damaged.