With
the change in administrations, the view that the problem with the
economy is a lack of regulation is proliferating on the web, on
radio talk shows, in blogs, news articles, and with the mainstream
media special interest groups. This view is being parroted in
response to news articles as the population glows with the
expectation that the new administration will put reins on an
unchecked free market that is being blamed for all of our financial
woes. The truth, as usual, is quite the opposite.
In 2007, according to Wayne Crews of the
Competitive Enterprise Institute, roughly 50 regulatory agencies
issued 3,595 final rules, ranging from boosting fuel economy standards for
light trucks to continuing a ban on
bringing torch lighters into airplane cabins. Five departments (Commerce,
Agriculture, Homeland Security, Treasury, and the Environmental Protection Agency) accounted for
45 percent of the new regulations. With
new bureaucracies being created by the Stimuls
Bill, the number of agencies issuing federal regualtions is
increasing.
Since
the Republicans assumed control in 2001, there has been a 13 percent
decrease in the annual number of new rules. However, the new
regulations’ cost to the economy will be much higher than it was
before 2001. 159 of the new rules are considered to be economically
significant, costing taxpayers $100 million or more per year. The
number of these high cost regulations has increased by 70 percent
since 2001. And at the end of 2007, another 3,882 regulations were
already at different stages of implementation. 757 of the new
regulations target small businesses.
The fact is that during this Republican
administration, there has been a significant increase in regulations and
cost since 2001. The number of pages added to the Federal
Register, which lists all new regulations, was just over 14,000 since
2001 during the Bush Republican administration. The total number of pages of
regulations on the books is over 130,000 in 201 volumes and takes up 20
feet of shelf space. There were over
3,000 pages pending at the end of the Bush administration and Harry
Reid has bullied a bill with another over 1,300 pages through the
Senate.
This has increased from 55,000 in 1970 during Republican and
Democratic administrations.
According
to George Mason University’s Mercatus Center, and Homeland
Security’s own estimate, its regulations alone cost the economy more
than $4 billion a year and the actual cost is much higher when you
consider the total effect that adversely affected industries have on
other industries. The Office of Management and Budget lists the
categories of regulation as either social, economic, and
process. The Congressional Review Act passed in 1996 allows Congress
60 days to review all new regulations imposed by regulatory agencies
for cost, legality, fairness, and economic impact before a new
regulation goes into effect.
As
you can guess, this is not enough time to pour through 135,000 pages
of federal regulations in three major areas and adequately discover
what adverse effects one regulation my have on all three areas, let
alone evaluate the thousands of new regulations that are subject to
review at any one time. Add to this the effect that a new federal
regulation might have on state regulations
when California alone has over 300,000 pages of regulations effecting business alone
plus another entire volume of building code regulations. In order
to do this, legislators would have to be experts on all
industries when they clearly are not expert on one and each Senator
and Congress member would have to be familiar with all state, county, and
local regulations in the areas that they represent. As we have seen in the
deficit and transportation, airline, telecommunications, housing, and auto industries, this can only
lead to disastrous results.
To continue to take on
an impossible task can only lead to failure. This is why the
Constitution, which does not give our federal public servants the
power to regulate, assigns less complicated tasks to our
legislators. They only have to protect our liberty, rights, and
property, defend our borders, and be friends with other
countries. None of
these things are being accomplished while they are subject to the
pressure and exposure to corruption that is generated by special
interests.
The free market that allowed this country to
become the strongest economic power in
the world, also clearly, no longer exists. It accomplishes nothing to
mistakenly rail against a myth that will soon, along with
the Constitution, become a legend.